youtube pinterest twitter facebook instagram vimeo Bookmark Entries BURGER NEW Chevron Down Chevron Left Chevron Right Basket Speech Comment Search Video Play Icon Premium Nigella Lawson Vegan Vegetarian Member Speech Recipe Bookmark Comment Camera Scales Quantity List Reorder Remove Open book
Menu Signed In
More answers

Black Cake Frosting

Asked by amon. Answered on 12th June 2011

Full question

Hi, I want to make a birthday cake and to colour the frosting black. I don't know how to make black frosting - can you help please?

Our answer

It is quite difficult to get a true black colour on cake frosting and many times they turn out a deep purple rather than black. However there are a couple of things that can help to get a dark, almost-black colour. The first is to use a gel paste rather that liquid food colour as it is much more concentrated and you will generally get a stringer colour when using pastes.

The second its to use a chocolate frosting as it already has a dark base colour. Using a white or pale frosting base will result in either a grey-coloured frosting or you will need to add so much food colour to make the frosting black that the food colour will make the frosting taste bitter. You may have a favourite chocolate buttercream recipe that you can use, or try the All-Purpose Chocolate Icing from Domestic Goddess (p195), beating in the food colour a little at a time after the vanilla and rum have been added.

If you are wanting to colour ready to roll (Regalice/rolled fondant) icing then we would suggest looking for icing that is already coloured black as this will always have a much truer black colour than you can achieve at home. Some UK supermarkets sell boxes containing 4 small packages of pre-coloured icing, which includes black, Wilton sells a "natural" colours pack which includes black. You can also buy chocolate-flavoured ready to roll icing from cake decorating suppliers which again will be easier to colour with black if a large quantity is needed.

Tell us what you think